The Piano Lesson is an intriguing film that weaves together family drama, trauma rooted in legacy, and elements of a ghost story. It has moments of brilliance, but also some unevenness along the way. The performances are a standout, with Danielle Deadwyler delivering a phenomenal portrayal—she truly anchors the film and brings emotional depth to every scene. Ray Fisher is also impressive, offering humour and a steady presence, though I found myself wanting more from his character. He skilfully balances being the comedic relief while still adding layers to the story’s tension and heart.
While the film’s second half picks up momentum, the pacing throughout feels inconsistent. The first half is particularly slow, and while there’s a turning point that re-engages the audience, certain scenes drag on, while others rush by too quickly. The ending, though unexpected, left me feeling somewhat unsatisfied, as it didn’t tie up the themes in a way that resonated with the emotional groundwork laid earlier in the film. It felt like a missed opportunity to fully explore the powerful ideas the story introduces.
Overall, it’s a solid directorial debut, but the film’s structure and setting might have been better suited to the stage. Much of the action takes place in a single location, and the dialogue-heavy scenes feel like they would shine more in a theatrical production. This story, with its complex family dynamics and rich history, might resonate more deeply when experienced as a play, where its themes could unfold with the nuance and intimacy they deserve. I’m now curious to watch the play to see if it brings out the full potential of this powerful narrative.
What's Your Reaction?

Elijah is one of the three creative minds behind Geeks of the Week, a platform dedicated to exploring the worlds of film, TV, and pop culture. Alongside his co-creators, Elijah covers everything from blockbuster premieres to hidden gems in the industry, offering a blend of insightful analysis and passion for storytelling. By day, Elijah is a civil engineering technician, and by night, he taps into his technical expertise and love for narrative to connect with fellow fans and inspire aspiring filmmakers.